
Medical Malpractice in Surgery
Attorney Natan Ron | Partner and Founder, Ron-Festinger Law Office
Medical malpractice in surgery is a departure from the accepted standard of care before, during or after the operation - from the absence of informed consent, through negligent performance of the procedure, to poor follow-up of complications and infections. An important distinction: a surgical complication is not, in itself, malpractice. The legal question is whether the team acted as a reasonable physician would have acted in the same circumstances - and where the answer is no and harm was caused, there may be grounds for a claim.
Every operation carries known risks, and even a flawless operation can end in a complication. But there is a difference between a risk that materialized and a failure that could have been prevented: between expected bleeding and a blood vessel injured by poor technique; between a rare infection and an infection whose signs were ignored for days. That distinction - between a possible risk and malpractice - is the heart of this page.
Did you undergo an operation that went wrong, and you are not sure it had to happen? Schedule an initial consultation at no cost: 077-4075002 | also available on WhatsApp
When is a complication in surgery considered medical malpractice?
The test has two parts. First, did the conduct depart from accepted medical practice - in preparation, in performance or in follow-up. Second, was it the departure that caused the harm, as opposed to a known risk that materialized despite proper treatment. These questions are decided by the opinion of an expert in the relevant surgical field, based on the operative report and the medical records. In some cases, where the circumstances "speak for themselves", the burden of proof may shift to the treating team.
Negligence before the operation
- No informed consent. An operation performed without the patient receiving a full explanation of the risks, the chances of success and the alternatives, as required by the Patient's Rights Law
- Wrong indication. An operation that was not necessary, or that was chosen over a more suitable alternative
- Inadequate preparation. Preliminary tests not performed, background conditions not taken into account, medication not stopped or adjusted. At times the preliminary tests are exactly what should have revealed a reason not to operate (a contraindication), and failing to perform them can in itself establish liability
Negligence during the operation
- Injury to adjacent organs, nerves or blood vessels. Beyond the reasonable risk of the procedure
- A foreign object left in the body. Swabs, instruments - among the clearest cases of negligence
- Operating on the wrong organ or side. A failure of identification and marking - another clear case of negligence
- Anesthesia failures. In risk assessment, in monitoring during the operation or in responding to events. For more: medical malpractice in anesthesia
- Poor conditions and equipment. Including instrument sterilization failures and contamination of the operating room
Negligence after the operation
- An infection not identified or treated in time. Fever, unusual pain or discharge that was not investigated
- Poor follow-up of complications. Internal bleeding, clots, leaks - discovered late
- Discharge too early. Or incomplete discharge instructions that did not allow the patient to recognize warning signs
- Failure of continuity of care. A finding during the operation that required further investigation and was not addressed
Common types of operations in malpractice claims
The principles of liability are the same in every surgical field, but each type of operation has its own characteristics. Prominent areas in claims include gynecological and obstetric operations - first and foremost medical malpractice in cesarean section; medical malpractice in plastic surgery, where the patient's expectations and informed consent carry special weight; orthopedic surgery; abdominal and bariatric surgery; and eye and laser surgery. In each of these fields we work with leading surgical experts.
How is negligence in surgery proven?
- Collecting the full documentation. The operative report, the anesthesia chart, the consent forms, and the records from the hospitalization and the follow-up afterwards. Every patient has a legal right to receive their records
- A preliminary review by a lawyer experienced in the field. Identifying signs of departure from accepted practice
- An opinion from a surgical expert in the relevant field. Was there a departure from the standard, and did it cause the harm
- Assessing the harm. The disability, the impairment of function and earning capacity, and future treatment needs
- Filing and managing the claim. Against the hospital, the medical institution or their insurers
The importance of documentation - when the record is missing, it does not work against you
The patient is under anesthesia and cannot testify to what happened in their body - which is why the law gives decisive weight to the medical documentation. The law and case law require a full and detailed record of the course of the operation and of the explanations given before it. When the records are poor or missing, this works in favor of the plaintiff: a significant action that was not documented may be regarded, in evidentiary terms, as an action that was not performed - and the burden of proof may shift to the treating team.
Compensation and the statute of limitations
Compensation is derived from the harm and may include medical and rehabilitation expenses, loss of earnings, assistance from others, necessary adaptations, and pain and suffering. As a rule, a claim is time-barred after seven years, but the date the harm was discovered - for example a foreign object found years after the operation - affects the count, and for minors the count generally starts at age 18. It is advisable to seek an assessment as early as possible.
The experience of the Ron-Festinger firm in surgical malpractice claims
The Ron-Festinger firm has represented victims of medical malpractice for more than 44 years, in surgical cases of every kind: from obstetric operations to general surgery, orthopedics, neurosurgery and plastic surgery.
The initial assessment of the case, including a first review of the medical records, is free of charge. The legal fee is collected as a percentage of the compensation only if the claim succeeds.
Below are examples of cases our firm has handled. Each case is examined according to its specific circumstances, and the results of previous cases do not indicate results in other cases.
Surgery without informed consent
Surgery for excessive sweating that ended in paralysis of the arm
Our firm handled the case of a young woman who suffered from excessive sweating of the palms. She underwent a relatively simple operation under the armpit, intended to solve this minor problem.
She was not told at all that one of the possible risks of the operation was full or partial paralysis of the nervous system in the armpit area, which can cause severe injury to the arm.
A consent form signed in the corridor
The woman was made to sign the consent form for the operation in the hospital corridor, moments before the surgery. The signature was obtained by a hospital clerk, not by a physician as required.
The rare risk materialized, and the woman was left with severe paralysis of the arm.
The judgment
The court ruled that it could not be determined with certainty that the surgeons were negligent in performing the operation. However, it held that had the risk been explained to the woman, she might well have decided to forgo altogether an operation intended merely to solve a minor problem of excessive sweating.
The woman was awarded compensation of several hundred thousand NIS. The hospital appealed to the Supreme Court, which upheld the legal findings regarding the failure to give the woman proper explanations.
Negligence in follow-up after surgery
Knee arthroscopy and complaints that were not addressed
Our firm represented the widow and orphans of a man who underwent a simple, routine knee operation (arthroscopy).
At the post-operative check-up the man complained of unusual pain. The physician did not take the complaint seriously enough, nor the fact that there was a family history of blood clotting problems.
The night after the visit, the man developed a blood clot that traveled to his lungs and caused his death. A claim was filed, and a settlement of more than 3 million NIS was reached.
No instructions to the nursing staff after a leg amputation
A man with diabetes was hospitalized for the amputation of his right leg. After the operation the surgeons did not give suitable instructions to the nursing staff and, among other things, did not order that the patient be forbidden to get out of bed alone.
The man got out of bed alone and fell, and his left leg also had to be amputated. A claim was filed, and a settlement of 2 million NIS was reached.
Bleeding not diagnosed after cosmetic surgery
Our firm filed a claim on behalf of a woman who underwent a simple cosmetic surgical procedure under general anesthesia.
After the operation it turned out that she was bleeding, and she was taken for another operation. After she was discharged from the hospital it became clear that the bleeding had not stopped.
The operating surgeon did not diagnose this, and as a result of the loss of blood the woman suffered a heart attack.
No treatment to prevent blood clots after orthopedic surgery
A woman underwent a simple orthopedic operation in a hospital, but did not receive medication afterwards to prevent blood clotting.
A few days after her discharge she collapsed at home and was rushed to the hospital. There it turned out that she had suffered a pulmonary embolism caused by venous thrombosis. The clot also reached her brain and caused severe, irreversible damage, from which she died.
Compartment syndrome after surgery to repair leg fractures
A woman of about 60 underwent surgery to fix leg fractures after a fall. In the recovery room she was given regional anesthesia in the operated area, contrary to the guidelines and without the surgeons being informed.
When weakness was observed in her leg, the team did not perform basic tests to find its source, and the regional anesthesia made it harder to assess how serious the injury was. Only when it was too late did it emerge that compartment syndrome had developed - damage to the blood supply to the leg tissues - and amputation of the leg could not be avoided.
Shortly after the claim was filed, the woman died of a serious illness unrelated to these events. After negotiations with the hospital, her heirs were paid about 400,000 NIS in compensation.
Negligence during an operation
An infusion that caused necrosis in a premature baby's leg
A baby born prematurely underwent a routine abdominal operation to treat a congenital defect in the intestine. For the operation an infusion line was inserted into his leg, which caused necrosis.
The medical team did not identify the necrosis in time, and as a result amputation of the leg was unavoidable.
Closing a healthy blood vessel in brain tumor surgery
A woman underwent neurosurgery to remove a brain tumor. During the operation bleeding broke out, and the surgical team tried to stop it by placing clips on the bleeding blood vessel.
The clips were also placed on a nearby blood vessel that was not bleeding. As a result, the woman suffered a blood clot in the brain that caused her death.
To schedule an initial consultation: 077-4075002 | also available on WhatsApp
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a surgical complication and medical malpractice?
A complication is the materialization of a known risk, which can occur even with proper treatment. Malpractice is a departure from accepted practice - in preparation, in performance or in follow-up - that caused harm. The distinction is made by an expert opinion that analyzes the operative report and the records against what would be expected of a reasonable team.
What is informed consent, and when does breaching it give rise to a claim?
Informed consent is the physician's duty to explain to the patient, before the operation, the nature of the treatment, its chances, its risks and the existing alternatives - in a way that allows a free and informed decision (sections 12 and 13 of the Patient's Rights Law). If the explanation was not given as required, and the patient would not have agreed to the operation had they known the full picture, there may be grounds for a claim, even if the operation was performed properly.
The surgery failed - am I entitled to compensation?
Not every operation that did not achieve its purpose gives rise to a claim - success is not guaranteed in medicine. The question is whether the failure resulted from negligence: a wrong indication, poor performance, inadequate follow-up or lack of informed consent. If so, and harm was caused, compensation may be due. The initial assessment with us is free of charge.
Infection after surgery - when is it malpractice?
Infection is a known risk of every operation, so its appearance alone is not negligence. Negligence may exist where the infection resulted from a failure in sterilizing the surgical instruments or in the operating conditions, or - the more common scenario - where the signs of infection were not identified and treated in time, and the delay caused the harm.
What documents should I collect before contacting a lawyer?
If you have the hospitalization file for the operation - the operative report, the consent forms, the discharge summary and documentation of the check-ups after it - bring it to the meeting. If you do not have it, do not worry: every patient has a legal right to receive all of their records from the medical institution, and we take care of collecting the full documentation as part of the initial assessment.
How long do I have to file a claim for malpractice in surgery?
As a rule seven years from the event, but the date the harm was discovered may postpone the start of the count - for example when the harm was discovered years after the operation - and for minors the count generally starts at age 18. To avoid losing your rights, have the deadlines checked as soon as possible.
Contact us
An operation that went wrong leaves questions - and we are here to answer them honestly. An initial consultation at no cost: 077-4075002 | WhatsApp | or leave your details in the form at the bottom of the page | offices in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. No Win No Fee - legal fees only if the claim succeeds.
The content on this page is general information only, does not constitute legal advice and is not a substitute for individual legal advice. Every case is examined according to its circumstances. For a professional assessment of your case, contact us for an initial consultation at no cost and with no obligation.
Need Consultation?
Get professional consultation in Medical Malpractice in Surgery
Additional Areas of Expertise
Medical Malpractice in Anesthesia
Brain damage, awareness during surgery or nerve injury from anesthesia? When an anesthesia failure amounts to medical malpractice, how it is proven and what compensation covers. Free initial consultation - 44+ years of experience.
Medical Malpractice in Plastic Surgery
Medicine is advancing by leaps and bounds in the field of plastic surgery, and the demand for surgeries is growing. The most common surgeries are brea...
Medical Malpractice in Laser Surgery
Everyone wants to see 6:6. Everyone wants to get rid of their glasses and be free....
Medical Malpractice in Cesarean Section
A cesarean performed late, or not at all? A delay in an urgent cesarean can harm the baby. When it is malpractice and what to do. Free initial consultation.
Need Legal Consultation?
Contact us for professional consultation in Medical Malpractice in Surgery
