On This Page(40)
Claims Against Local Authorities for Slip and Fall Accidents: The Complete Guide
A claim against a municipality or local authority for a fall on a sidewalk, a pothole in the road or a hazard in a public space is possible – but it differs from a claim against a private business: you usually need to prove that the authority knew (or should have known) about the specific hazard, and that it was unreasonable not to repair it. There are special rules, unique evidence and legal obstacles that many people are unaware of – and lose their right to compensation because of them.
This article is part of the complete guide to slip and fall accidents on our site. In this article we will explain:
- The difference between suing a municipality and suing a private party
- What conditions must be proven
- The unique defenses available to authorities
- How the legal process works
- Examples of compensation
- Special cases – contractors, trees, ice and lighting
Fell because of a hazard in a public space and not sure you have a claim? An initial consultation is free and without obligation – by phone, on WhatsApp or through the contact form.
Why Are Local Authorities "More Protected"?
The Legal Rationale
Local authorities manage enormous infrastructure:
- Hundreds of kilometers of sidewalks
- Thousands of roads
- Parks, gardens and schools
- Sewage, lighting and drainage infrastructure
No one can expect every meter of sidewalk to be perfect at every moment.
The Relevant Law
The Torts Ordinance (Section 60), the Municipalities Ordinance and the Local Authorities Law – these laws are relevant to claims against authorities.
What Must Be Proven – Special Elements
In addition to the four usual elements (duty, breach, causation, damage – see the chapter on proving liability in slip and fall accidents), there are special points of emphasis in claims against authorities.
Special Element: The Authority's Actual Knowledge
In claims against authorities, the courts usually require that the authority knew about the hazard.
Why is this different?
- A municipality cannot monitor every meter of infrastructure at every moment
- So it is not enough that the hazard existed – you need to show that the authority knew, or should have known, about it specifically
How Do You Prove Actual Knowledge?
A. Previous Reports
- Did anyone report the hazard to the municipality before the accident?
- Renovation/repair requests that were filed and not handled
- Residents' complaints
How to find them:
- An information request to the municipality (under the Freedom of Information Law)
- Reviewing minutes of municipal committees
- Searching the local press
B. Inspections and Surveys
- Did the municipality conduct an infrastructure inspection and find the problem?
- Is there documentation showing the problem was known?
C. An "Obvious" Hazard No One Could Miss
- A sidewalk completely cracked along 10 meters – it is hard to claim "we didn't know"
- A huge pothole on a main road – it is implausible that no one knew
D. A Partial Repair Was Made
If the authority repaired part of the hazard (but not all of it) – that proves it knew!
Special Element: "Reasonableness of Not Repairing"
Even if the authority knew – the court asks: was it reasonable not to repair? Factors taken into account:
- Cost of repair – a very expensive repair against a limited budget?
- Priorities – were there more dangerous hazards the authority had to address first?
- Time since the report – how much time passed since the authority knew?
The more time that passed after the authority knew and did not repair – the stronger the claim.
The Authority's Common Defenses – and How to Respond
"We Didn't Know"
The argument: "The hazard was not known to us."
How to respond:
- Show previous reports
- Show that the hazard was completely obvious (a huge pothole, a fully cracked sidewalk)
- Show that there was no proper infrastructure inspection system
"It's Your Fault – You Didn't Look"
As in ordinary claims – contributory negligence. But: against authorities this defense is stronger, because "one must be careful in a public space".
How to respond:
- Show that the hazard was not visible (for example: a small pothole at night with no lighting)
- Show that a reasonable person would not have seen the danger
The Claim Process Against an Authority – Step by Step
Step 1: Collecting Authority-Specific Evidence
In addition to the usual evidence (see the chapter on where accidents occur and the evidence to preserve):
✅ An information request to the municipality (Freedom of Information Law, 1998):
- Request: "All documents relating to complaints/reports about [hazard address] in the past three years"
- The authority must respond within 30 days
- If it refuses – you can turn to the Freedom of Information Commissioner
✅ Minutes of the municipal infrastructure committee – was the issue raised in discussions?
✅ Annual maintenance plans – did the hazard appear on the list of things to fix?
✅ Historical images – Google Street View lets you see historical images of the location. Sometimes they show the hazard existed years before the accident!
✅ Neighborhood witnesses – neighbors living near the hazard who can confirm how long it has existed.
Step 2: Expert Opinion
A civil/infrastructure engineer:
- Assesses whether the hazard met the standards
- Estimates how long the hazard has existed (based on the degree of wear)
Estimated cost: ₪5,000-15,000.
Step 3: Filing a Claim in Court
After collecting the evidence, a statement of claim is filed, as in any civil claim. Which court:
- Up to ₪2,500,000 – Magistrates' Court
- Over ₪2,500,000 – District Court
Step 4: Discovery of Documents
This stage is especially critical in claims against authorities! Demand disclosure of:
- All previous complaints about the hazard
- Maintenance and inspection procedures
- Infrastructure budgets
- Relevant minutes
Authorities sometimes object to discovery – in that case you can ask the court for a discovery order.
Step 5: Settlement or Trial
Local authorities usually prefer to settle – so as not to create case law that will bind them in the future. How long it takes:
- To settlement: 1-3 years
- To judgment: 3-6 years
Want to understand your chances against the authority? Ron-Festinger Law Office represents injured people in claims against local authorities on a No Win No Fee basis – legal fees are contingent on success. Contact us for a free initial consultation or message us on WhatsApp.
What Compensation Is Awarded in Claims Against Authorities?
Comparison to Claims Against Private Parties
In general, compensation in claims against authorities is similar to compensation in claims against private parties.
Examples of Compensation
The following examples are provided for illustration only. Each case is examined on its merits, and the outcome depends on its specific circumstances.
Case 1: A Fall on a Cracked Sidewalk – Haifa
- A 65-year-old woman fell on a sidewalk with a significantly protruding tile
- A hip fracture, surgery and 4 months of rehabilitation
- It was proven that the hazard was known to the municipality (a complaint 3 months earlier)
- Compensation: ₪280,000 (after a 20% deduction for contributory negligence)
Case 2: A Fall Into a Pothole – Tel Aviv
- A cyclist fell into a pothole in the road at night
- A leg fracture and 6 weeks in a cast
- It was proven that the pothole had existed for 4 months, based on historical Google Street View images
- Compensation: ₪140,000
Case 3: A Fall in a Municipal Park – Jerusalem
- A man tripped on a broken path in a park
- Knee damage and surgery
- The claim was dismissed – the court held that the authority's knowledge was not proven, and that a natural path with slight unevenness is not a "hazard"
Case 4: A Child Who Fell in a Municipal Playground
- An 8-year-old boy fell from a faulty piece of equipment
- A broken arm
- It was proven (with an engineer's opinion) that the equipment did not meet the Israeli standard
- Compensation: ₪95,000
Special Cases – What About...?
A Fall on a Street Maintained by a Contractor
Scenario: The municipality hired a contractor to repair sidewalks, and you fell near the work area. Who is liable?
- The contractor – if it did not fence off/mark the area properly
- The municipality – if it did not supervise the contractor
Usually both are sued, and the court will divide liability between them.
Fallen Trees or Branches
Scenario: A branch of a public tree fell on you or caused you to trip. Who is liable? The municipality – if the tree was in a public area and was not properly maintained. What must be proven:
- That the tree was at risk of falling (tree disease, visible dry branches)
- That the municipality knew – or had a regular tree inspection that should have discovered it
Freezing Rain and Ice
Scenario: You slipped on ice that formed overnight. This is more complex:
- Ice that has just formed – hard to sue over (the authority could not have known and acted in time)
- Ice that remained for hours in the morning while the authority did nothing – there are grounds for a claim!
Important: In cities with regular snow and ice (such as Jerusalem and Safed), the authority has an ice-handling procedure. Failing to carry it out may be considered negligence.
Poor Lighting
Scenario: You fell at night because of a broken streetlight. Who is liable? The municipality – it is responsible for street lighting. What must be proven:
- That the lighting was not working (photos, witnesses)
- That the municipality knew (monitoring systems, previous reports)
- That the darkness caused you not to see the hazard
A lighting engineer's opinion can help prove that the lighting level did not meet the standard.
Special Tips for Claims Against Authorities
1. Photograph the Wider Surroundings Too
Not only the hazard itself – also photograph:
- Street names and house numbers nearby
- Public signs nearby
- The general condition of the sidewalk/street
Why: It allows the exact location to be identified, and shows the connection to public infrastructure.
2. Check Historical Google Street View Immediately
Google Street View keeps historical images – sometimes going back years. How:
- Open Google Maps
- Enter Street View
- Click "See more dates" (the clock icon with the year)
- If the hazard appears in older images – take a screenshot!
This is excellent evidence that the hazard existed long before the accident.
3. Ask the Neighbors
Neighbors who live near the hazard are valuable witnesses:
- "How long has this sidewalk been broken?"
- "Did you report it to the municipality?"
- "Do you know of other accidents here?"
4. File a Freedom of Information Request Immediately
Don't wait – file a request with the municipality right away:
- "All documents relating to complaints/reports about [address] in the past three years"
- "The municipality's infrastructure maintenance procedures"
Response time: 30 days. If there is no response – contact the Freedom of Information Commissioner.
5. Don't Talk to Municipal Representatives Without a Lawyer
Municipal representatives (or the municipality's insurer) may try to:
- Get you to say that the hazard was obvious
- Offer low immediate compensation
- Obtain statements from you that will be used against you
Whenever a representative of the authority contacts you – it is best to refer them to your lawyer.
When Should You Contact a Lawyer?
In a claim against a local authority – almost always. The burden of proving the authority's knowledge, the need for freedom of information requests and document discovery, and the engineering opinion that is usually required – all of these make the process more complex than a claim against a private party.
Ron-Festinger Law Office has represented injured people in personal injury claims and claims against insurance companies – including slip and fall accidents and claims against local authorities – for more than 44 years, with offices in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. The initial consultation is free of charge and without obligation, and representation is on a No Win No Fee basis – legal fees are contingent on success. Available 24/7, including on WhatsApp.
Summary – Checklist for a Claim Against a Local Authority
✅ Immediately after the accident:
- Photograph the hazard from every angle
- Collect witness details
- Get medical treatment and document it
- Check historical Google Street View
- Ask neighbors about the hazard's history
✅ Within weeks:
- File a freedom of information request with the municipality
- Contact a lawyer who specializes in torts
- Check whether an engineer's opinion is needed
✅ What must be proven:
- A real hazard (not an obvious or natural danger)
- The authority's knowledge (usually required!)
- That a reasonable time passed and the hazard was not repaired
- A clear causal link to the injury
✅ Remember – the authority's knowledge is required more than in claims against private parties:
- An engineer's opinion – usually essential
- Freedom of information – a powerful tool for uncovering evidence
- Historical Google Street View – can prove the hazard existed for years
Frequently Asked Questions – Claims Against Local Authorities
Can I sue the municipality for a fall on the sidewalk?
Yes. A municipality is responsible for maintaining the sidewalks and roads within its jurisdiction, and if you fell because of a hazard (a protruding tile, a cracked sidewalk, a pothole) you can sue it. However, you usually need to prove that the authority knew or should have known about the specific hazard, and that it was unreasonable not to repair it.
What is the difference between suing a municipality and suing a private business?
The courts recognize that an authority cannot monitor every meter of infrastructure at every moment. So in a claim against an authority there is special emphasis on the authority's knowledge of the hazard and on the reasonableness of not repairing it – taking into account cost, priorities and the time that passed since it learned of it.
How do you prove that the municipality knew about the hazard?
Through previous reports and complaints (which can be located with a freedom of information request), documentation from infrastructure inspections, historical Google Street View images, testimony from neighbors, or a partial repair the authority carried out. A particularly prominent hazard – such as a huge pothole on a main road – makes it hard for the authority to claim it "didn't know".
How long does the municipality have to answer a freedom of information request?
Under the Freedom of Information Law, the authority must respond within 30 days. If it refuses or does not respond – you can turn to the authority's Freedom of Information Commissioner.
How long does a claim against a local authority take?
To settlement – usually 1-3 years; to judgment – 3-6 years. Local authorities often prefer to settle so as not to create case law that will bind them in the future.
Is compensation from an authority lower than from a private party?
Usually not. Compensation in claims against authorities is similar to compensation in claims against private parties, but it may be reduced for contributory negligence – a defense that authorities frequently raise.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. To have your case reviewed, book a free consultation with the lawyers of Ron-Festinger Law Office.

Attorney Natan Ron
Partner and Founder
Attorney Ron is one of Israel's senior attorneys in the field of torts, with over four decades of experience representing clients in challenging cases before various courts, including the Supreme Court.
View Profile
